| 
    
       
WHAT IF: Golden Age Strange Tales Vol. 5 
Map by Chris Leazer: reprints Strange Tales #41-50
(259 pages)
December/55: Strange Tales #41 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Joe Maneely (pencils); Joe Maneely,
Carl Burgos? (inks)
 
- "The Riddle of the Skull" (5 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Fred Kida (pencils);
Fred Kida (inks)
 - 
text story
 
 "The Search" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - "The Fishman" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Bill Everett (script); Bill Everett
(pencils); Bill Everett (inks); Bill Everett (letters)
 - 
"The Strange Stick" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Sale (pencils);
Robert Sale (inks)
 - 
"They Won't Believe" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Dick Ayers (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Man In the Dark" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Orlando (pencils);
Joe Orlando (inks) 
 
January/56: Strange Tales #42 (24 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Sol Brodsky (pencils); Sol Brodsky
(inks)
- "The Faceless One" (5 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Bill Everett
(pencils); Bill Everett (inks); Bill Everett (letters)
 - text story
 
 "The Collector" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Man Who Said No" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Maneely (pencils);
Joe Maneely (inks)
 - 
"Moon-Man" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bernie Krigstein
(pencils); Bernie Krigstein (inks)
 - 
"The Vanishing Brain" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Doug Wildey (pencils);
Doug Wildey (inks)
 - 
"The Man In the Cell" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Powell (pencils);
Bob Powell (inks) 
 
February/56: Strange Tales #43 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Russ Heath (pencils); Russ Heath (inks)
- "The Man Who Lived Twice" (5 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Tony DiPreta
(pencils); Tony DiPreta (inks)
 - text story
 
 "The Swami" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"I Saved Mankind" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); John Forte (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Behind the Mask" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Brown (pencils);
Bob Brown (inks)
 - 
"The Mysterious Machine" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Larry Woromay
(pencils); Steve Kirkel (inks)
 - 
"The Unbelievable Man" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Forgione (pencils);
Jack Abel (inks) 
 
March/56: Strange Tales #44 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Sol Brodsky (pencils); Sol Brodsky
(inks)
- "The Man Who Ran Away" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Forgione
(pencils); Bob Forgione (inks)
 - 
"One World At a Time" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Orlando (pencils);
Joe Orlando (inks)
 - text story
 
 "The Stone" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Mysterious Border" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Sale (pencils);
Robert Sale (inks)
 - 
"Look Out Below" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Powell (pencils);
Bob Powell (inks)
 - 
"Safari In the Sky" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Ed Winiarski (pencils);
Ed Winiarski (inks)
 - 
"Take a Giant Step" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Paul Reinman (pencils);
Paul Reinman (inks) 
 
April/56: Strange Tales #45 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett
(inks)
- "Land of Vanishing Men" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Sinnott (pencils);
Joe Sinnott (inks)
 - 
"The Night People" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Forgione (pencils);
Jack Abel (inks)
 - 
"The Eyes of Mr. Moody" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Jack Keller (pencils);
Jack Keller (inks)
 - 
"The Strange Exchange" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Ed Winiarski (pencils);
Ed Winiarski (inks)
 - text story
 
 "The Impersonation" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Man Who Went Back" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bernie Krigstein
(pencils); Bernie Krigstein (inks)
 - 
"Sorry, Wrong Planet" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bernard Baily
(pencils); Joe Sinnott? (inks) 
 
May/56: Strange Tales #46 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Carl Burgos (pencils); Carl Burgos
(inks)
- "The Sands Are Running Out" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Sinnott (pencils);
Joe Sinnott (inks)
 - 
"The Man From Nowhere" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Orlando (pencils);
Joe Orlando (inks)
 - 
"Repeat Performance" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); John Severin (pencils);
John Severin (inks)
 - text story
 
 "Planet X" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Wild, Wild Wind" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Dick Ayers (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"You Must Not Look" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Paul Reinman (pencils);
Paul Reinman (inks)
 - 
"The Greatest Experiment" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Steve Ditko (pencils);
Steve Ditko (inks) 
 
June/56: Strange Tales #47 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Sol Brodsky (pencils); Sol Brodsky
(inks)
- "When Mankind Vanished" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Frank Bolle (pencils);
Frank Bolle (inks)
 - 
"Overflow" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Tony DiPreta (pencils);
Tony DiPreta (inks)
 - 
"When Sorcerers Meet" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob McCarty (pencils);
Bob McCarty (inks)
 - 
"The Trial of Dr. Volton" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Ed Winiarski (pencils);
Ed Winiarski (inks)
 - text story
 
 "Magic Melody" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The New Member" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Vic Carrabotta
(pencils); Vic Carrabotta (inks)
 - 
"The Hands" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Jim McLaughlin
(pencils); Jim McLaughlin (inks) 
 
July/56: Strange Tales #48 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Carl Burgos (pencils); Carl Burgos
(inks)
- "The Deserted Lighthouse" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Forgione
(pencils); Jack Abel (inks)
 - 
"The Man Who Stole a Skyscraper" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Manny Stallman
(pencils); Manny Stallman (inks)
 - 
"The Men In Space" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bill Walton (pencils);
Bill Walton (inks)
 - 
"I've Got To Hide" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Mort Meskin (pencils);
Mort Meskin (inks)
 - text story
 
 "Muscle Man" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"Medicine Man" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Ed Winiarski (pencils);
Ed Winiarski (inks)
 - 
"The Last of Mr. Grimm" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Dick Ayers (pencils);
Dick Ayers (inks) 
 
August/56: Strange Tales #49 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett
(inks)
- "Inside the Black Bag" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Mac Pakula (pencils);
Mac Pakula (inks)
 - 
"The Girl Who Saved the World" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Orlando (pencils);
Joe Orlando (inks)
 - 
"Not Quite Human" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Christopher Rule
(pencils); Christopher Rule (inks)
 - 
"What Happened To Mr. Smith" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Harry Lazarus
(pencils); Harry Lazarus (inks)
 - text story
 
 "The Weatherman" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Animal" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bob Brown (pencils);
Bob Brown (inks)
 - 
"The Man Who Cried" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); John Forte (pencils);
John Forte (inks) 
 
September/56: Strange Tales #50 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett
(inks)
- "The End of the Line" (4 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Paul Reinman
(pencils); Paul Reinman (inks)
 - 
"Both of Me" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Harry Lazarus
(pencils); Harry Lazarus (inks)
 - 
"The Fog The Couldn't Lie" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Steve Ditko (pencils);
Steve Ditko (inks)
 - 
"The World Outside" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Bill Benulis (pencils);
Bill Benulis (inks)
 - text story
 
 "The Newshound" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Needle Swings" (3 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Robert Sale (pencils);
Robert Sale (inks)
 - 
"Sleep, You Fool" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); John Forte (pencils);
John Forte (inks) 
Mockup image by:  David Spofforth 
  
   |