| 
       
WHAT IF: Mystery Tales Vol. 2 
Map by Chris Leazer: reprints Mystery Tales #12-22
(286 pages)
June/53: Mystery Tales #12 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Joe Maneely (pencils); Joe Maneely
(inks)
 
- "The Room That Isn't There!" (6? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - "The Scavenger!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Never Say Die" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Assassination!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
July/53: Mystery Tales #13 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Sol Brodsky (pencils); Sol Brodsky
(inks)
- "unknown" (5? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Joe Sinnott (pencils);
Joe Sinnott (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Ross Andru (pencils);
Ross Andru (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Chuck Winter (pencils);
Chuck Winter (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Ogden Whitney
(pencils); Ogden Whitney (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
August/53: Mystery Tales #14 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Bill Everett (pencils); Bill Everett
(inks)
- "Don't Ever Gyp a Gypsy!" (5? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"Listen, You Fool!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Marion's Murderer" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Today I Am a Man" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
September/53: Mystery Tales #15 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Russ Heath (pencils); Russ Heath (inks)
- "The Vampire's Coffin!" (5? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"The Little Monster!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"Johnny's Last Jump!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"The Man In the Tank!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
October/53: Mystery Tales #16 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks)
- "Bring Back My Feet!" (5 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Genuine Alligator" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Myron Fass (pencils);
Myron Fass (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
January/54: Mystery Tales #17 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Russ Heath (pencils); Russ Heath (inks)
- "The Movie House Horror!" (5? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"What Happened Up There!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"The Black Crows" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"The Man Without Eyes!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Paul Reinman (pencils);
Paul Reinman (inks) 
 
March/54: Mystery Tales #18 (25 pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks)
- "The Lonely Dungeon" (5 pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "Peril From the Cave" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"Into the Fourth Dimension" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Gene Colan (pencils);
Gene Colan (inks)
 - 
"Up!" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Vince Colletta
(pencils); Vince Colletta (inks)
 - 
"The Graveyeard!" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Missing Persons!" (5 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
May/54: Mystery Tales #19 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Harry Anderson (pencils); Harry
Anderson (inks)
- "In My Graveyard There Walks a Corpse!" (6?
pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (6? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
July/54: Mystery Tales #20 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Bill Everett? (pencils); Bill Everett?
(inks)
- "The Stone Man!" (6? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"Crime Wave" (4 pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Martin Thall (pencils);
Martin Thall (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Hy Rosen (pencils); Hy
Rosen (inks) 
 
September/54: Mystery Tales #21 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: Unknown (pencils); Unknown (inks)
- "The 13th Floor!" (6? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
 
October/54: Mystery Tales #22 (25? pages +
cover) 
Cover Credits: John Forte (pencils); Matt Fox (inks)
- "The Boy Who Believed!" (6? pages)
 
  Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"The Rejected Robot!" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Jack Abel (pencils);
Jack Abel (inks)
 - text story
 
 "unknown" (2 pages)
 Credits: Unknown (script)
 - 
"unknown" (3? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (4? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks)
 - 
"unknown" (5? pages)
 
 Credits: Unknown (script); Unknown (pencils);
Unknown (inks) 
Mockup image by:  David Juell 
  
   |